Do It Right the First Time, By Kayode Oladipupo
Security institutions are not ordinary bureaucracies. They carry arms, exercise coercive power, restrict liberty, and, in extreme circumstances, determine who lives and who dies. If Nigeria is to establish state police, it must be guided by a simple yet powerful principle associated with Japanese quality management: do it right the first time and continuously improve thereafter.
The Japanese philosophy of Kaizen, meaning continuous improvement, is often misunderstood as merely correcting mistakes as they occur. Its deeper lesson is far more demanding: build quality into the process, identify weaknesses at their source, and continually improve the system so that defects are prevented rather than endlessly repaired. That philosophy should guide Nigeria’s emerging security architecture.
The case for state police has become increasingly compelling. Nigeria, with over 200 million people, vast territory, porous borders, and diverse security challenges, still operates a predominantly centralized policing system. The security realities of Zamfara are not the same as those of Lagos; the challenges in Benue differ from those in Rivers; and what works in Borno may be unsuitable for Anambra.
Effective policing depends heavily on local knowledge. Officers need to understand their communities, languages, terrain, social networks, and emerging threats. A policing structure that brings decision-making closer to the people could improve intelligence gathering, response times, and public confidence. But legitimate concerns remain.
Can governors be trusted with direct control of armed police formations? Could state police become private armies used to intimidate political opponents, journalists, protesters, and civil society organizations? What happens during elections when the ruling party in a state controls the policing machinery? Who protects citizens from a governor determined to weaponize law enforcement?
These concerns are neither imaginary nor partisan. Nigeria’s political history provides ample reason for caution. The abuse of federal security agencies by successive administrations already demonstrates what can happen when coercive institutions become vulnerable to political influence. Decentralizing police power without decentralizing accountability could simply multiply the problem thirty-sixfold. This is precisely why Nigeria must do it right the first time.
State police should not be created merely by transferring control of armed officers from Abuja to state governors. The reform must involve a comprehensive redesign of the national security architecture, backed by constitutional safeguards that are stronger than the political interests of any officeholder.
An independent State Police Commission should oversee recruitment, appointments, discipline, and the handling of complaints. Its composition must prevent domination by governors or ruling parties. Commissioners of State Police should enjoy secure tenure and should not be removable at the pleasure of a governor.
There must also be enforceable national standards governing recruitment, training, weapons management, intelligence protocols, remuneration, and compliance with human rights. A police officer in one state should not operate under professional standards that are significantly inferior to those applicable elsewhere.
Funding is equally critical. An unpaid armed officer is a security risk. States seeking to establish police forces must demonstrate sustainable fiscal capacity. Salaries should enjoy first-line charge protection, while police budgets and procurement processes should be subject to independent audits. Nigeria must avoid creating armed institutions whose survival depends on the discretionary generosity of political officeholders.
Jurisdiction must also be clearly defined before the first state police officer takes to the streets. Who handles terrorism, cybercrime, interstate kidnapping, or criminals who cross state boundaries? What happens when federal and state police issue conflicting directives? Who commands joint operations during national emergencies? Ambiguity within the security architecture is, in itself, a security threat.
The Japanese concept of Jidoka building quality and automatic problem detection into a system is particularly relevant. State policing must incorporate mechanisms capable of detecting abuse early, stopping it promptly, and addressing its root causes. Independent complaints bodies, judicial oversight, legislative scrutiny, public reporting, and civilian accountability must not become afterthoughts.
Nigeria should also resist the temptation of a simultaneous nationwide rollout. A phased implementation based on clearly defined readiness criteria would be far wiser. States with adequate fiscal capacity, institutional structures, training facilities, and accountability mechanisms could commence first. Their experiences should be independently evaluated, with lessons incorporated into subsequent phases.
Doing it right the first time does not mean expecting perfection. Kaizen itself rejects complacency. Rather, it means thinking deeply before acting, preventing foreseeable defects, and remaining committed to continuous improvement after implementation.
Nigeria undoubtedly needs a security system that is more responsive to its size, diversity, and evolving threats. But replacing excessive centralization with unchecked local political control would merely exchange one weakness for another.
The question, therefore, is not simply whether Nigeria should establish state police. It is whether the country possesses the creative wisdom to build a system that combines local intelligence with national coordination, operational effectiveness with democratic accountability, and coercive power with constitutional restraint.
On state police, Nigeria may have only one opportunity to get the foundations right. We should not create tomorrow’s security crisis in our attempt to solve today’s insecurity. Think deeply. Anticipate abuse. Build safeguards. Establish accountability. Do it right the first time and then never stop improving.
Oladipupo, Chief Executive Officer, KEMKAY Consults, is a Public Policy Advocate.




